157 Comments

My substack needs to be ultra-non-private. I need a Substack that is viral.

Expand full comment

LOL, for realz. Building more walls is not for me, I need to offer express lanes.

Expand full comment

Express lanes - love this phrase

Expand full comment

Mine need both. The community-building substack https://onhumanity.substack.com would appreciate more readers and “virality”, while my newer “thoughts and ideas” one seems like a perfect fit for this private mode feature. How many of you out there are in a similar position?

Expand full comment

I can't figure out what good numbers are. I've been on since the beginning of June and only have 87 followers. I don't know if that's good or bad. I could definitely use a little virility--oh wait, that's what the wife said--I meant "Virality." I could use a little Viral boost. With all I'm doing, I don't think I have the time to start another page. But I think it's a great idea!

Expand full comment

That’s pretty good man, 2 months for me here with a post every week and I’ve gained 0 followers.

Expand full comment

I followed you because you deserve more followers. Just keep putting out quality stuff and the readers will come. It's in the comments where people will see your name and look at what you have to offer. Personally, I don't leave enough comments, but that might be because I don't feel that I'm qualified to leave a comment. But who doesn't have a special quote, or snippet of a poem in their head that they take along with them through their lives? "Listen my children and you shall hear Of the midnight ride of Paul Revere."

Expand full comment

Now that quote made me laugh and took me back to my childhood:)

Expand full comment

Please be my first paid subscriber and read my articles .

Expand full comment

Isn't it cool? And I'm not even American. I've got about until, "just as the moon rose over the bay..."

Expand full comment

Thank you for the encouraging words, the new quote, and the follow I truly appreciate it. I followed you back as well!

Expand full comment

Please be my paid subscriber ..

Expand full comment

Please be my paid subscriber ..❤️

Expand full comment

Just signed up — the post on reaching the end of your rope was insightful!

Expand full comment

That's the one that caught my attention too!

Expand full comment

Thank you my friend! You’re my first non family sub, I also returned the favor.

Expand full comment

I'll be honest- the 'suggested read time' (or whatever the correct term is) did put me off a little, as someone with a 'tempremental' attention span and liited time I am drawn to things under 10 min. But I share an interest in quotes and am interested to have a better read when I have a bit more time. If you're interested in a potential collab/ cross post in the future, I have a number of quotes I've had in mind for disecting for a while and I reckon it could be a great fit!

Expand full comment

Certainly a possibility and I thank you for the consideration. I also subscribed back to you and read through a couple articles. The opening line to your ADHD post made me laugh!

Expand full comment

'Fun times'? That's what my (Also ADHD) friend said to me the next time we spoke after the suggestion I get assessed!😂

Expand full comment

Follow similar substacks and comment. Your comment is tagged with your Substack. I picked up quite a few followers that way.

Expand full comment

Thank you for the advice, I definitely will.

Expand full comment

Keep writing good sir!

Expand full comment

Thanks for sharing! I just started reading The Bashful Courtesan and subscribed to Scribbler. It looks interesting! Do you use any social media to publicize your writing?

Expand full comment

I'm on Facebook and twitter, and used linked in. I also send out emails, but I don't have a big list. And thanks for subscribing!

Expand full comment

Please be my paid subscriber and read my articles. I swear you will enjoy .

Expand full comment

Writer referrals and networking with influencers is key if that is your goal.

Expand full comment

#same I've been in the publishing business for decades now, and it's getting harder and harder to find readers. Even when offering free short stories etc, I'm having a hard time finding new subscribers. But at this point, I'm more concerned with finding my love for writing good stories again.

Expand full comment

As quotes is my niche - “You firemen run nothing but a circus. The public stopped reading long ago.”

I feel you though. I’m brand new into this though so I am only seeing what it’s like now a-days.

Expand full comment

Plz be my 1st paid subscriber 🤩🤍

Expand full comment

Dang, my account must be set to private by accident because I’m writing into a journal apparently.

In all seriousness though that’s a great feature to get comfortable before going live, I like that idea!

Expand full comment

Ha! I feel this one more than I should.

Expand full comment

Plz visit my account and be my first paid subscriber .Dont mind brother

Expand full comment
Comment deleted
Expand full comment

There is a solution to the annoying pings -if you go into Settings on your phone, scroll down to Notifications,and scroll further to find Substack, you’ll be able to switch off the sounds. Peace will then reign but you might then miss an article which you’d want to read. I think switching off the banners in Notifications may also solve the problem on your computer, but if I went upstairs to my computer to test this, I would wake the dog, which would be a bad idea!

Expand full comment

I just took my private Substack public after populating it for 10 months in front of a small audience of friends (l used a paywall and then comped free subscribers with a paid account, a little hacky but it worked).

Definitely recommend, especially if you're just trying to find your voice and/or getting into the habit of regularly publishing for an audience.

Expand full comment

Thanks for mentioning this hack. It was in the back of mind to try it. Glad to know it works.

Expand full comment

Love all the community features. On the app side, it would be great to enable voice transcription to draft multiple posts. That way writers can work on content on anywhere!

Expand full comment

Have you tried Otter Ai for this? I keep thinking to give it a go (do an audio post, have otter transcribe it and then use that to do the written version of the post) but haven't spent enough time getting to grips with it yet.

Expand full comment

I feel you guys. Might as well plug in my newsletter: zedletterday.substack.com

Expand full comment

I started my newsletter in private mode for a few months while I was getting started and it gave me a chance to experiment, make changes, and find my path forward without distractions. I love it, and I'd definitely use it for more personal, intimate newsletters as well.

May not be possible, but "private mode" for individual sections within a newsletter could be worthwhile...

Expand full comment

Okay so for people wondering how this works and benefits other than “the cool kids” social media-esque exclusivity:

I made another substack earlier this month documenting the feelings and motions I’ve been going through since my mom passed last month.

I wanted it to be private, but didn’t have that option. I just wanted small groups I trusted who were also caregivers for loved ones to see it because I wasn’t trying to market it or anything; they were literally my own thoughts and feelings during a pretty vulnerable time.

I think it’ll help for moments like that, or like if you truly wanted to just have a substack for a small group you could make it private so people didn’t have to pay for a more casual substack that has a smaller, more intimate audience.

I loved substack too much to write anywhere else to share those thoughts!

Expand full comment

Sorry to hear about your mom. My dad is going that direction. I write about it on SS.

Michael Mohr

‘The Incompatibility of Being Alive’

https://reallife82.substack.com/

Expand full comment

Thank you so much; I left a comment on your latest post because I enjoyed how you took me on a journey of what you’ve been through and how it’s changed recently!

Leaving the rest of my response here cause it’s more relevant haha. But yeah, I can’t write like I used to on my main Substack. None of my queued ideas and drafts feel “right” anymore, and literally nearly everything I think of writing is laced in mom’s passing (like the aftermath or just reflections).

I was her full time caregiver for 8 years, a few weeks after I graduated college (so I stayed home with my dad, bro, and her). So now, I feel like I’m getting to live life for the first time, and it’s slightly overwhelming at 31 to be starting for the first time.

Death and grief is weird and rough! Resized I experienced anticipatory grief for months before she passed, and maybe even a full year before it happened.

Lots of thoughts, lots of thoughts. A wild ride overall!

But thanks for letting me know about your substack, and your condolences!

Expand full comment

Subscribed to your stack just now btw ❤️

Expand full comment

Aw thanks so much!

Expand full comment

Ah, I thought I did but saw I didn't when I rolled over your name just now! Did the same so I can keep following along!

Expand full comment

Wow: 8 years! You are a saint of some sort. Hey: 31 is still very young :) You’ve got everything ahead of you! Maybe go travel a bit? I feel excited for you.

Expand full comment

Haha, thank you. It was definitely a ride of ups and downs for sure, no saint here! Wanted to help my mom, and the time just passed in the meantime, until it had to end.

Traveling's definitely an option down the line! I'm currently trying to find my footing with even getting jobs/careers/a more stable grip on my identity currently, but I'd love to travel!

I'm literally gonna have to watch college kids and see how do they just... DO things, whether alone or with a friend (I have a feeling I'll be doing quite a bit alone). Kinda scary for me at the moment, not gonna lie!

But I'm excited too, and to document! Thanks again!

Expand full comment

And I honestly might use it as I rebrand. Turn it on private make it feel exclusive and ask people on IG to leave their emails if they want in and tease it 👀 I dunno! Just rambling!

Expand full comment

This is an epic new feature!! It helps me feel more comfortable writing so vulnerably to the community of 'Explorers' as I call them. I felt in my last post (my most vulnerable post to date) I had triple the number of views as I did subscribers and I know it was because curious people off my social media wanted to snoop and read - but not subscribe. If they are interested, I hope they are invested to be apart of the wonderful community of explorers. I appreciate this feature for my Substack sooo much! https://www.thehumanatlas.live/

Expand full comment

I have so many of those "snoop and peak" people too! I feel you.

Expand full comment

Thank you Yuezhong! The stats are so revealing for this! I love this feature as it further fuels my courage to write with no filter for the community of 'Explorers' - not the entire internet of stalkers haha :)

Expand full comment

Thanks! Perfect, I’m checking it out!! I’m guessing that this new feature will be a big hit because so many of us are on Facebook Fumes and have no interest wading into Twitter or joining other social media platforms like Social, Getter, etc. This option is promising for quality not quantity in content.

Expand full comment

THIS is brilliant!!

Expand full comment

This is a cool idea! I hope though that this doesn’t lend itself toward more and more of a social media app. But a neat way of engaging people into the Substack world.

Expand full comment

I also fear the increasing move toward social media mimicry...

Expand full comment

Agree. And that’s not a road we want to go down.

Expand full comment

Good point. Let’s keep it about writing.

Expand full comment

Thank you for this! I would love to have a way to create private posts, or private sections of a public substack, if possible.

Expand full comment

Yes! This. I don’t want my whole publication to be private but having the option for certain posts or sections would be great.

Expand full comment

I have an active substack but would like to make it private. I don't see that option in the settings. Can someone please help? I followed the instructions but I don't see the option.

Expand full comment

The setting — in my Settings page, is called “Private mode”.

Expand full comment

I don’t see that. I’ve been looking for 20 mins!

Expand full comment

It's in the box that says "Import your email list" for some unknown reason. It's a button you toggle.

Expand full comment

No wonder I didn’t see it either. Ty

Expand full comment

My undergraduates use invitation-only Substacks in my introductory journalism course. This allows them to practice weekly publishing and develop newsletters without exposing their experiments or identities to the entire internet. We all invite the rest of the class. Some invite family or friends too. Most students wind down their publications at the end of the semester, but a few go public and continue after the course ends.

Expand full comment

This is a great idea! Hadn't thought of that use case. Sounds like you're creating a safe space or your students to spread their wings.

Expand full comment

Love this! I’m sure lots of people will put private Substacks to good use. Equally cool, a product like private will bring more readers to the Substack network, which is good for growing writers.

Expand full comment

Can public Substackers make private Substack part of their web sites? What if someone wants private Substacks for family, friends, close neighbors, colleagues etc. How would they set that home. Can you create home pages like we have in our newsletters?

Expand full comment

Hi Donald, today you can only make an entire publication private, not just specific sections. If you'd like to send a Substack to family, friends, close neighbors, and colleagues then you'd need to set up another publication.

Expand full comment

It would be great to be able to make private sections.

Expand full comment

Could this work like a private tab or would the whole Substack be private?

I mean, there’s already levels of exclusivity with free and paid. This seems like a velvet rope for the cool kids. I guess I’m just puzzled by this. Seems like (again) bigger substacks would benefit from this especially if they get a lot of trolls.

Expand full comment

The whole Substack would be private with this new update

Expand full comment

So you need a private Substack for each group of readers?

Expand full comment